Last Saturday evening I bought 2 gallons of milk at Trader Joes. We just finished the first gallon so I opened the second one tonight. It tasted off. I checked the date and it was "use by Sept 9" which was last Sunday.
Do you think they will allow me to exchange? Technically it wasn't past its use by date on Saturday when I bought it, but to drink it within the use by date from when I bought it, we would've had to drink it all on Sunday.
Also, I searched and no longer have my receipt. Do you think that's a problem? I'm going to have my husband call and ask.
I seem to be having bad luck with milk lately. In the past 6 weeks or so this is the third gallon that has been bad (the other two were terrible and still within their sell by dates but from a different store). All were organic. They obviously sit on the shelves longer. Normally I'd toss it but $5.99 per gallon? I'm not tossing it!