I don't know...maybe I'll get flamed for this, but if the student truly did waste time before rushing to put something on paper, I think your response was appropriate. I think that kids today have learned that they can rush through things, cry, and get their way. I'm not sure I'd apologize. It seems like you are teaching them that they have to put their best effort forward or there are consequences -and crying won't eliminate those consequences. I think that is an appropriate lesson.
I have several students who have been skipping after school music lessons that are required for a special class they are in. Yes, they are young and it is probably on their parents that they forget, but our music teacher has made them start skipping recess to make up the lessons. Some of my kids were whining about it to me. I just told them that they agreed to go to the after school lessons, we send a schedule and I remind them of their times. If they are skipping or being forgetful -accidentally on purpose - I don't feel bad for them. When you agree to do something, you must do it. It is a valuable lesson that many of my students won't learn at home. I think it is the same with your test taking effort issue. Our job is to teach them to use their best effort. Sometimes I think we try to use too much compassion and kids learn that they can manipulate the system to get what they want.
I flat out told a boy the other day that I was really frustrated with him. I said, "I'm not mad at you because you don't understand how to do this problem, I'm mad because every time I try to explain it to the class you refuse to listen. When I came over here to explain it to you, you only halfway listened and put your head down. When you act like you don't care or want to learn it makes me very frustrated." This boy has been playing the "I don't understand" game all year. Yet, he never puts fort any effort towards understanding, no matter how many interventions we have provided. He is in the process of being tested, but his answer is to put his head down and tune everything out. That drives me insane.
Then again, maybe I'm just in a foul mood because my sweet, innocent, 3rd graders have discovered cuss words this week and are using them like it is their job! Truthfully, I haven't and I don't plan to show much compassion with that.
