Use m&ms or the letters in their names.
One difficult problem I gave them after teaching probabillity was:
If I had the letters T R E N T O N in a bag what was the probability of pulling out an "N" however, the worksheet had letters falling out of a bag and two of them staying inside. A letter "N" and "O" were left unseen, so of course many of them said 1 out of 5. Practice, practice, practice....
